Reshingling house: Remove chimney or re-flash it?
We are about to have our 1 1/2 story, nearly 100 year old house re-shingled. I am wondering which option to go with regarding the chimney. We can have the roofers re-flash it and keep it or they can remove it.
We wouldn’t have it removed all the way to the basement though. They would remove the brick to below the level of the roof, then stuff the chimney with insulation, patch the roof deck and shingle overtop.
We live in Manitoba, Canada with cold winters and lot’s of snow. Is there a benefit (or a downside) to either option in terms of energy savings through less heat loss. Any other benefits or downsides (moisture issues, maybe)?
The chimney is no longer required as the hot water is electric and the furnace is high-efficiency. I guess I lose the option of a hot water tank ever going back to natural gas without a chimney.
Has anyone ever had this done before? What do people recommend?
There is no fireplace. The chimney is currently not used. The furnace vents out the side of the house and the hot water tank is electric.
Also the chimney is not on the side of the house. It comes up through the middle of the roof.
I don’t think lack of support under a re-sheeted section would be a problem as it is at most 2 square feet. The new boards would be supported by the nearest rafters.















